Knowing Is Half The Battle: Dark City, The Matrix, And Inception As Gnostic Manuals

Topic started by keonichavez on May 13, 2011. Last post by Xpgamer7 2 years ago.
Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff
Just another doodle on Terry Gilliam's desk.
Just another doodle on Terry Gilliam's desk.

When hearing the word "religion", it's a safe assumption that most people will think of the more commonly referenced faiths, like Islam, Catholicism, declaring for Ba'al, what have you. However, I'd like to talk about an often-overlooked sect of Christianity (though even that stipulation is arguable) called Gnosticism.

Essentially -- and know that this is a gross oversimplification, but for the purposes of this article, it'll do -- the Gnostics believed that the material world was an imperfect reflection of a higher, truer reality. This imperfection was created, not by God, but by a lesser being known as a 'demiurge'. While the purpose for this creation isn't always clear, it was said that only by adherence to esoteric knowledge -- or "gnosis" -- can one transcend the trap of the material world and ascend to the higher plane.

Now, run that notion through Hollywood's lens, and what do you get? At least the three movies mentioned in the title: Alex Proyas' Dark City, The Wachowski Brothers' The Matrix, and Christopher Nolan's Inception.

To be clear, I'm not saying that these directors (or the writers of the scripts) were necessarily thinking Gnostically when they made these fine films, merely that they all possess elements that are strikingly similar to the principles outlined above.

Whoa... now that you mention it... these movies are kinda similar...
Whoa... now that you mention it... these movies are kinda similar...

In Dark City, we meet John Murdoch, who awakens in a bathtub with little memory of how he got there, or what's going on. Over the course of the movie he begins to put the big picture together, encountering supernatural resistance along the way, and eventually ascends to a place of full knowledge -- and thus, full power -- and begins at last to shape his world to suit him, instead of being at the mercy of forces he didn't previously understand.

The Matrix follows the same plot, with Neo being further along the path of knowledge at the start of the movie than John was, but still unaware of the true nature of his reality. In Inception, Cobb is an acknowledged master of his reality-shaping craft, and his rise to knowledge takes the form of a difficult event he must acknowledge and accept responsibility for before he can achieve real enlightenment.

In which way are these movies any different from the usual rise to power found in most adventure stories? The key element is in the nature of the characters' understanding of reality itself. In each of these, there is a baseline universe that is hidden to those without the proper knowledge of how to access it. In Dark City, control is achieved through "tuning", a way to influence matter through the power of the mind. In The Matrix, the running computer simulation that informs the title of the movie is so convincing that special effort must be made to overcome the illusion and see the world for what it truly is. In Inception things are a little reversed: reality is fine, but through proper training, one's dreams can be shaped into worlds as real-seeming as anything.

These movies -- and to a more obvious parallel, The Truman Show, which hit theaters the same year as Dark City -- exemplify the radical notion that our reality is not what we assume it to be. In fact, the imperfect apprehension of reality is what causes the general dissatisfaction that we feel as humans. Morpheus's speech to Neo lays this all out; in our very beings, we know there is something wrong with the world, but we can't quite figure it out. That search for knowledge, layered heavily over with action, has made for some truly memorable films, and vibrant, wide-ranging philosophical discussions. Whether or not these movies accurately represent the true Gnostic viewpoint, or were even meant to, is best left for the individual to ascertain. What's important about these movies is the way they opened up the minds and imaginations of an otherwise blissfully-unaware public to the notion that questioning reality is a worthwhile pursuit that will put them one step closer to enlightenment.

Can you think of any other films that might be interpreted as Gnostic parables?

Post by ThatFrood (321 posts) See mini bio
I agree with this, though the inclusion of Inception is a bit of a stretch.
Post by dethmunky (1 posts) See mini bio
  
   I love this kind of stuff.    http://youtu.be/dfDIVJXkfCU
Post by TehJedicake (17 posts) See mini bio
That was a very interesting read :D
Post by Seraphim84 (67 posts) See mini bio
It's necessary to be vague so I apologize, but The Nines could be seen in a similar light as these movies as well.
Post by PieINyourFACE (122 posts) See mini bio
While not religious in any sense, I believe Moon may be able to qualify. Like the Truman Show, we are introduced to a character who lives in a reality he believes is real, until a series of events takes place that shatters that illusion.
Post by Mento (98 posts) See mini bio
I'm not sure the Gnostic parallel was considered too heavily when writing these movies (though the Matrix wouldn't surprise me), but I would believe that they share a similar inherently human philosophical itch that both Gnosticism and these high-concept movies attempt to scratch. It's a powerful notion - that you're in an imperfect world that isn't real and acknowledging it is the first step towards escape - regardless of its source.

I'd never considered it before, because it seems like a bad idea to think too hard about anything in that show, but Aeon Flux had a literal demiurge as the focus of one episode. It pretty much acted as the one you mentioned would, creating perfect worlds (via illusions) that were imperfect by their very nature as illusions, with the perennial antagonist Trevor wanting to use its powers to keep his people under control and Aeon wanting to blast it off into space (presumably because it couldn't be destroyed, though who knows). Already my head is hurting.
Post by ArchTeckGuru8 (38 posts) See mini bio
I love this stuff.

I also really like that image, zero idea what is going on in it, whats it called?
Post by ArchTeckGuru8 (38 posts) See mini bio
Forgot to add, the Roger Ebert commentary track to Dark City is fascinating and really adds to just how good that movie is.  If you can find an edition that has it on it, I highly recommend you give it a listen.

Waking Life would be another movie to mention, at least the vague overarching story of it.

Also maybe Ghost In The Shell?
Post by ScanCase (893 posts) See mini bio
Moderator

This is definitely an interesting idea. This is certainly a new lens I can filter some films through.

Post by circle (405 posts) See mini bio
The Thirteenth Floor

One of those Hollywood studio copycat situations ala Deep Impact/Armageddon. The Thirteenth Floor released the same year as The Matrix with very similar themes. I'd go as far to say a cross between Tron and The Matrix with a noir murder mystery as its main plot device.

The Thirteenth Floor I have seen once and remember liking it quite a bit so I can safely recommend it. I do need to watch it again though to confirm.
Post by bybeach (30 posts) See mini bio

Nice drawing. It looks like The Dark City and Inception just made the list. I have heard of a movie called vanilla sky, also.
Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@thatfrood: You're right, it is, but interesting enough to make the parallel, I thought.

Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@dethmunky: Thank you for that link; I love that kinda stuff too, and even more when it's presented in a positive, "you can get this" kinda way. It may be time for me to re-watch Donnie Darko.

Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@tehjedicake: Thank you! It could have gone on quite a bit longer, but I wanted to spare you all the headache.

Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@Seraphim84: Haven't seen that one; will check it out, thanks!

Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@PieINyourFACE: That's high on my 'must-see' list... maybe this week I'll finally pull the trigger!

Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@mento: I have no trouble believing that that show was wildly referential of a great many things, though it was so incredibly hyperstylized that one could have used it to prove almost any philosophical point. Great mention!

Post by ryanwho (1,130 posts) See mini bio
PK Dick was a hardcore gnostic and his last years were spent on rambling religious documents. This is just one of those things where certain religions appeal to certain people. Gnosticism is hardcore nihilism essentially.
Post by keonichavez (0 posts) See mini bio
Staff

@archteckguru8:I'm not sure what it's called or who created it (haven't done the research -- yet) but I found it here: http://starweaverwitch.wordpress.com/2008/03/31/gnostics-and-pagans/

113 votes, 4.2 avg.

  • 3.6

  • 77

  • 66

  • 7.8

  • B
General Information Edit
Name Dark City
US Release Feb. 27, 1998
UK Release May 29, 1998
AUS Release Aug. 6, 1998
Runtime 100
Language(s)
Add a new language
Genre(s)
Add a new genre
Theme(s)
Rating R
Alias(es)
Top Rated Lists
Wait...WHAT THE HELL!? a list of 26 items by RainbowReelCinema
Mindbenders a list of 32 items by Strange_Bundle
My Top 35 Favorite Films a list of 35 items by TearsInRain
  • In today's dollars
    Domestic $14,378,331
    Foreign +12,821,985
  • = total worldwide gross $27,200,316
Top Editors
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel