Which Oscar Nominee Should Have Won??

Topic started by VioletEyedDragon on March 17, 2012. Last post by Black_Rose 1 year, 1 month ago.
Post by VioletEyedDragon (1,813 posts)

Cast your vote

Once you make your selection the rest of the community's votes will appear.
  • The Artist
  • The Descendants
  • Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
  • The Help
  • Hugo
  • Midnight in Paris
  • Moneyball
  • The Tree of Life
  • War Horse
Post by GreatestEver99 (183 posts) See mini bio

My heart was with Midnight in Paris. Such a delightful little movie. Now that I think of it the last few years the winner has been predictable and everybody is sure who's gonna win and every other nomination is kind of just honorable mentions. Am I just crazy or do I have a point.

Post by Mushir (1,149 posts) See mini bio

I haven't seen The Artist, but out of the nominations that I have seen, I liked Midnight in Paris the most. It left me with a really good feeling and the cinematography was brilliant that really showed off the beautiful city that is Paris.

Post by ashogo (754 posts) See mini bio

Hugo, without a doubt. Aside from the core (great) film, the 3D was genuinely fantastic and actually added to the experience.

Post by litrock (560 posts) See mini bio

Melancholia up there? No? Well, I suppose Tree of Life, then. I would also accept Hugo as a rational choice.

Post by Red (508 posts) See mini bio

I really, really, really enjoyed Moneyball, Hugo, and Midnight in Paris. Any of those would've been fine in my book. The only other movie on that list I liked was the Artist, which, while pleasant and unique, just wasn't as good as the praise it's been getting, aside from that which was toward Jean Dujardin.

If I had to choose one, it'd probably be Midnight in Paris, mainly because it got me to finally cast aside my long-time hatred of the French. Well, at least Parisians.

Post by TheFaithfullyDeparted (1,921 posts) See mini bio

Well i haven't gotten around to most of those but from the ones I saw Moneyball was a great film to watch and I would have been a good pick

Post by VioletEyedDragon (1,813 posts) See mini bio

@litrock said:

Melancholia up there? No? Well, I suppose Tree of Life, then. I would also accept Hugo as a rational choice.

these are only the movies that were nominated for Oscars.

Post by litrock (560 posts) See mini bio

@VioletEyedDragon: I know. I'm still carrying a torch. Stupid Oscars.

Post by privateirontfu (41 posts) See mini bio

Moneyball or Hugo. I really, really enjoyed Hugo. Way more than I thought I would.

Post by activatetheasset (65 posts) See mini bio

Did anyone see all 9 movies? I only made it to 6 myself.

Post by VioletEyedDragon (1,813 posts) See mini bio

@litrock said:

@VioletEyedDragon: I know. I'm still carrying a torch. Stupid Oscars.

my pick for best film wasnt nominated either. (I picked Everything Must Go).

@activatetheasset said:

Did anyone see all 9 movies? I only made it to 6 myself.

i saw all nine, but i dont really have a life ;)

Post by Black_Rose (591 posts) See mini bio

Either Midnight in Paris or Tree of Life. I have no intention of ever watching The Help as I care little about its subject matter or the awful-looking Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close.

Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel