Like most Whiskey sites, abandon any hope of your podcast being short and embrace the inevitability of a 2 and a half hour podcast.
and Maybe you guys should schedule your podcasts earlier so you're not worrying about Giant Bomb bursting through the door, so we can have proper 2 hour podcasts? I'm pretty sure most users here would agree on longer podcasts. You don't always have to talk about the current films or box office, I'm sure you guys watch older movies in your spare time and maybe do a "does it hold up?" segment.
And yes, you guys should screen the questions beforehand if you have the time as homework before going to bed, and select which questions you're going to answer on the podcast.