Casting Call: The Flash (Updated)

Topic started by CrimsonAvenger on Jan. 16, 2012. Last post by CherryBomb 1 year, 4 months ago.
Post by CrimsonAvenger (1,277 posts) See mini bio
The Flash Family
The Flash Family

Over the years, there have been numerous characters to take up the mantle of The Flash. First there was Jay Garrick, then Barry Allen, then to Wally West, then to Bart Allen, and then back to Barry Allen. There's been a Flash movie in development for some time now but it hasn't been said which Flash will be in the film but Geoff Johns has hinted that it will probably be Barry Allen. He didn't say whether it would be but it does seem likely that Barry will be The Flash in the film.

The Flash though is going to be an extremely difficult character to the big screen but it can be done. Green Lantern could have been great but it sadly failed at bringing such a famous character to the big screen. It definitely is not impossible to bring either to the big screen but I'm sure there will be some difficulties. All the project needs though is a director who can make it work on the big screen. It also depends on which Flash is chosen for the film. Many fans want Wally West, I for one do not. For me Barry Allen is The Flash, no question about it and Wally West was just a placeholder.

Director: Brad Bird

Brad bird
Brad bird

I know I'm probably alone in saying this but I think Brad Bird could helm a Flash movie. He's got The Iron Giant, The Incredibles, Ratatouille, and Mission: Impossible: Ghost Protocol under his belt and everyone of those films are great. With The Incredibles, Brad Bird proved that he could take on the superhero film genre and do incredibly well with it. This man can tell an incredible story where you can more about the characters than the action. OK, so Mission Impossible didn't do that but since when has that franchise ever been about its' characters? I don't think anyone else can helm a Flash movie; certainly not Martin Campbell who couldn't even handle Green Lantern.

If Brad Bird can make the movie in a way like Iron Man with his style of doing things and a story by Geoff Johns, then you've got one hell of a Flash movie.

Barry Allen: Neil Patrick Harris

Neil Patrick Harris
Neil Patrick Harris

There is an actor I am enormously fond of because he's so damn cool and actually looks a ton like Barry Allen, I'm talking about Doogie Howser himself, Neil Patrick Harris. He actually has voiced Barry Allen before in Justice League: The New Frontier and just cemented my belief that he should be Barry Allen. In fact the guy looks like Barry Allen in the comics and I wouldn't be surprised if Francis Manapul drawing Barry a bit like Neil Patrick Harris.

Some people seem to think he'd be a good Wally West but I'm a bit puzzled by that because he strikes me as more of a Barry Allen Flash rather than Wally West. Bradley Cooper whom many want as Barry is more like Wally than Harris.

To put it plain and simple, you won't find a better Barry Allen than Neil Patrick Harris.Sure there's Ryan Gosling but as much as I like Ryan Gosling, I just could not ever cast anyone else besides Harris. People love this guy already and he is the Flash no matter what anyone may think, you just can't deny that he is the physical equivalent to Barry Allen.

Wally West: Bradley Cooper

If Ryan Reynolds wasn't Hal Jordan or Deadpool, I'd suggest him for the role of Wally West but the thing he could never do it. So I have to say Bradley Cooper is the next best choice for the role primarily because of his charm. I don't know anything about Wally West so he is the funny Flash right? If so then yeah Bradley Cooper should play him. The only problem though is that he couldn't be more disinterested in playing the character. He's been asked about and never gives an answer so yeah playing a superhero is not on his list of things to do.

I'm only familiar with Wally West because of Justice League and Young Justice so my casting choice may be way off for all I know but still I think Cooper could do it even though I don't a thing about Wally West other than he was the third Flash. Or heck while we're at it, why not just cast Michael Rosenbaum?

Iris West Allen: Blake Lively

You can guess why I chose this photo
You can guess why I chose this photo

One of the things I didn't really like about the new DC Universe was splitting up Iris and Barry. They were by far my favorite couple and I know I'm going to get some flack for my choice for this role because the actress is already playing another DC character although isn't widely liked as her. I'm talking about Blake Lively whom I've always felt should have been Iris West instead of Carol Ferris.

Of all the many DC love interests, Iris West is by far my favorite. It's hard to explain why but I just like the character quite a lot. Of course I do have a second choice, Mila Kunis. Kunis is an actress I love because she is just so funny and I'd love to see her do so many roles including Iris West and heck maybe even Princess Leia if there ever were a remake of Star Wars.

Professor Zoom: John Wesley Shipp

Wally and Barry don't really have the greatest villains. Like the Justice League has the Legion of Doom, The Flashes have the Rogues. Now the Rogues would not work in a movie so if it is Barry in the film, then I have to choose to Professor Zoom AKA Eobard Thawne. So to play the role, I have to choose John Wesley Shipp who has not only voice the character but was once upon a time Barry Allen himself in that terrible 1990's TV show titled The Flash.

Don't get me wrong I love a few of the rogues like Captain Cold, Mirror Master, and Captain Boomerang but the other two: Weather Wizard and The Trickster? I don't think so. They are to me quite possibly some of the lamest comic book villains of all time especially the Trickster.

Assuming John Wesley Shipp can physically play the character, it would be awesome and he's certainly got the voice for it as his performance as Professor Zoom in the episode "Requiem for a Scarlet Speedster" was pretty awesome. The problem with most of the Superman movies is that he wasn't given someone he could actually fight and I hope that mistake isn't made in The Flash movie. So the best choice is to go with a character who is The Flash's equal.

Zoom: Michael Rosenbaum

I'm going to say right now, I don't give a shit about Hunter Zolomon AKA Zoom. I think he's a vastly overrated and overpowered character and in comparison to the other Reverse-Flashes is nowhere nears as cool. I'd love to see Rosenbaum reprise the role of Wally West from Justice League but in live-action but at the same time, why not have him play Zoom?

Is there really anyone else that could play him? Garrett Hedlund maybe? Like I said I don't care about this character very much and will never understood why people love him so much but if Michael Rosenbaum were casted as him, I think I could be convinced that Hunter Zolomon is a worthwhile villain.

The Rogues

I think if there is anyone who can make the Rogues work in a movie, it'd have to be Brad Bird. Now The Rogues are actually probably the only group of villains that could hold their own film. If you got rid of Weather Wizard and replaced him with Captain Boomerang and deleted the Trickster all together, then they become an actually menacing group.

If this film does end up having the Rogues as the villains, then I'd love to see them get a prequel film directed by Quentin Tarantino. It would have them doing some sort of heist and Tarantino is a pro at that kind of stuff and has been looking to do a comic book movie for some time now.

CharacterActor
Captain Cold
Captain Cold
For Captain Cold, I have to say Guy Pearce. Pearce is an actor I really want to play Doctor Strange but if I had to choose, I'd definitely say Captain Cold. For those of you who don't know who Captain Cold is, I'll explain. Captain Cold originally debuted in the 1950's in the Silver Age of Comics and has since been one of Barry Allen's greatest enemies if not his greatest. In fact if Pearce was unavailable, one could just hire Lex Lang who has voiced the character in the past but he doesn't do live-action films though.
Heat Wave
Heat Wave
As stated in the comments, he'd choose Sam Worthington for the role. I'm not a huge fa of Sam Worthington but yeah, I like the idea of him as Heat Wave. Heat Wave is a pyromaniac and originally a rival to Captain Cold. That's about all I can say about him.
Since Mirror Master is Scottish, I feel obligated to cast a Scottish actor in the role because I like to be correct with these things. There are very few Scottish actors I know of that aren't Sean Connery so I have to go with David Tennant for the role. Like many, The Tenth Doctor also holds a special place in my heart because he was that one I really grew to love for a number of reasons. He's anxious to do something else other than Doctor Who even though he loves being known for his role on that show and I think Mirror Master is a great role for him.

A second choice for the role is another sci-fi actor-Paul McGillion of Stargate: Atlantis fame. I really enjoyed him as Doctor Carson Beckett and would love to see what he could bring to the role of Mirror Master.
Captain Boomerang was once a lame villain but that all changed after he became of the Suicide Squad which oddly enough is being adapted into a movie but it probably will feature the current roster. Boomerang is an Australian so I feel he should be played an Australian actor. Preferably I'd like it to be Eric Bana who plays him but I'll settle for Hugh Jackman as well.
Post by Mercy_ (104 posts) See mini bio

Stop having perfect casting choices O_O Jeez, I think I've only seen one or two that I don't agree with.

Post by CrimsonAvenger (1,277 posts) See mini bio

@courtney12490 said:

Stop having perfect casting choices O_O Jeez, I think I've only seen one or two that I don't agree with.

I can't help it. Now that I think about it, I should stop looking at a career in directing movies but instead casting them. What choices have you disagreed with me on? I've written so many of these I can barely remember which ones I've done.

Post by Dr_Ventum (18 posts) See mini bio

What makes Zoom interesting as a villain is how completely screwed up his logic is and how much he completely outclasses The Flash in the one area where very few can.

If Zoom were trying he'd be able to slaughter Wally, but he's not trying to kill Wally, he's trying to improve him. And his idea for improving Wally is ruining his life so that he'll be forced to focus on heroics. It's a scary just how far Zoom will go and it's great to see Wally go above and beyond his limits to stop one of his most dangerous foes ever. Admittedly I don't think Zoom works as a villain that appears more than a few times, but he's still at least a cool concept in my book.

Anywho, off topic stuff aside, I have no issue with these casting choices.

Post by Christina (1,656 posts) See mini bio

I just can't get on board with Neil Patrick Harris and I don't know why! It's not even like I have any better suggestions.

Post by Gambit1024 (104 posts) See mini bio

Brad Bird would be perfect for a Flash film.

I agree, NPH would be an excellent Barry Allen. I just think that Cooper is too old for Wally West, though.

I have a fan cast of The Rogues if you're interested :P

Post by CrimsonAvenger (1,277 posts) See mini bio

@Gambit1024 said:

Brad Bird would be perfect for a Flash film.

I agree, NPH would be an excellent Barry Allen. I just think that Cooper is too old for Wally West, though.

I have a fan cast of The Rogues if you're interested :P

I'd love to see anyone's casting of The Rogues. Besides Hugh Jackman as Captain Boomerang, I'd have no idea of who to cast for them or how to make them work on screen.

Post by Gambit1024 (104 posts) See mini bio

@CrimsonAvenger: Well I wouldn't know how to make them work on screen, but this is who I'd like to see for The Rogues:

Captain Cold- Paul Giamatti

Zoom- Garrett Hedlund

Captain Boomerang- Hugh Jackman

Weather Wizard- David Tennant

Heatwave- Sam Worthington

Mirror Master- Timothy Olyphant

Post by CrimsonAvenger (1,277 posts) See mini bio

@Gambit1024 said:

@CrimsonAvenger: Well I wouldn't know how to make them work on screen, but this is who I'd like to see for The Rogues:

Captain Cold- Paul Giamatti

Zoom- Garrett Hedlund

Captain Boomerang- Hugh Jackman

Weather Wizard- David Tennant

Heatwave- Sam Worthington

Mirror Master- Timothy Olyphant

I'll bold and underline the ones I particularly like. Ordinarily I'm not a huge fan of Sam Worthington but I'm not gonna lie him as Heat Wave would be pretty cool. David Tennant is certainly an interesting choice for the role of Weather Wizard; not sure though how I exactly feel about seeing him as that character but nonetheless I got to give you credit for coming up with that idea. Garrett Hedlund is currently my second choice for Zoom. Now if Hugh Jackman were casted as Captain Boomerang, I'd just die because is so perfect for the role. I think I'll edit this and add in a few more roles and credit you for the suggestion if I do go with one of your choices.

Post by Gambit1024 (104 posts) See mini bio

@CrimsonAvenger: Thanks :D

Captain Cold is still especially hard to cast. Paul Giamatti was just the first to come to mind.

Post by CrimsonAvenger (1,277 posts) See mini bio

@Gambit1024:

For some reason Captain Cold is the hardest to cast. Personally Captain Cold is my hands down favorite villain but I can't think of a single actor to play him.

Post by Gambit1024 (104 posts) See mini bio

@CrimsonAvenger: It really depends on what direction you'd want to go with him.

Post by PenguinDust (1,685 posts) See mini bio

I like a lot of your choices, but I can only see Bradley Cooper as Wally West if there is no presence of Barry Allen. If he's just a guy out there or if he's played by a different actor than Harris, then I'm, up for it, but otherwise, no. The problem is Wally West was "Kid Flash" before he became The Flash and so he needs to be younger in my mind. Now, Harris is older than Cooper but only by two years and I believe that's not enough for the mentor-protégé relationship. That was a big problem for me when they picked Chris O'Donnell for Robin in Schumacher's "Batman brought to you by Crayola" movies. So, someone to play Wally West should have some youth still as well. Cooper, right now is 37 which is fine for the character in a world where Barry Allen is an unseen mystery. It would be like adding Nathan Fillion as Jay Garrick.

So who would I pick? Well, it's hard to say since many young actors don't have very long resumes, however my choices would be something more along the lines of Joel Courtney, Nathan Gamble, or Jake T. Austin. If I was going to go with someone a bit older I'd say something like Skandar Keynes, Logan Lerman or Josh Hutcherson who are all in their low 20's. I know I am placing a lot of emphasis on age in my choices, but that's because there should be a big brother-little brother dynamic between the two characters of Allen and West.

Post by CherryBomb (1,255 posts) See mini bio

Awesome! (:

I'm a huge fan of Blake Lively, she'd be an an amazing, beautiful Iris.

Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel