Screened News

* GASP * Whedon Knew About the Buffy Remake Before... and he Passed on It!

More to this than apparent.


 They DID kind-of downplay the cheerleader angle as they went along, didn't they?
 They DID kind-of downplay the cheerleader angle as they went along, didn't they?

That talk of a Buffy remake last week provided plenty of gristle for the gnashin’, didn't it? 

Turns out there was more than what was immediately apparent. Whedon, for all the shock and surprise he expressed in his open letter regarding the matter, was actually more in-the-know than he seemed to be. THR’s reported that he was offered, and actually refused, to be part of this new project.  

I don’t think anybody ought to to fault him for not being totally forthcoming. If you read his statement and didn’t realize that a lot of it was phrased with tongue in cheek, then you probably don’t know the guy’s work well enough to be upset about a remake in the first place.

I’ve seen the original, of course, and a handful of episodes from the show, so I guess I'm quasi-knowledgeable about Buffy. However, isn’t a big part of the mythos supposed to be that the “slayer” is like the Pendragon, manifesting as different young ladies in different eras when the circumstances demand it? Wasn’t the premise of that Fray spin-off supposed to basically be Buffy 2099 (or Buffy Beyond, if you prefer?) So, and not to get too “meta,” but if a new slayer surfaces whenever the vampire threat looms, perhaps a new Buffy is needed to beat back the Twilight-spawned hordes? Just a thought.

Lydian_Selon Dec. 2, 2010 at 9:06 a.m.
I think if a Slayer came about to fight the sparkly vampires she'd be kinda bored, they all seem kinda soft, foppish, & self loathing.
handlason Dec. 2, 2010 at 9:06 a.m.
well the show had 2 slayers at one point.  I can't remember why.  It feels like so long ago.
 
Then the other slayer turned evil and hot slayer on slayer action ensued.
Martin_Blankon Dec. 2, 2010 at 9:09 a.m.
"Once in every generation..." I believe.
 
The first Buffy movie was pretty good in an early-90s-there's-nothing-else-really-to-rent-night way. Paul Reubens was easily the best thing about it.
  
  
 

MarkWahlbergon Dec. 2, 2010 at 9:22 a.m.
I'd thought those quotes you guys posted sounded more amused than anything else.
TheEggplanton Dec. 2, 2010 at 9:46 a.m.
They sort of retconned the "once every generation" thing in season 7 
And this story has been grossly misreported. 
http://whedonesque.com/comments/25419  
http://popwatch.ew.com/2009/06/12/joss-whedon-buffy-dollhouse-1/
hagridoreon Dec. 2, 2010 at 10:50 a.m.
When one dies another gets the mantle. Till season seven when Buffy activated all the potentials to slayers. 
 
Oh, and Buffy dies once early on creating another slayer position.
Martin_Blankon Dec. 2, 2010 at 1:31 p.m.
Besides... where's our Spike movie?!
Hadoken101on Dec. 2, 2010 at 2:25 p.m.
Quick rundown how how the Slayer thing played out. Also, Spoilers (sort of, the show fucking ended in '03)
 
Basically, every time a slayer dies, a new girl gains the powers, this isn't random though as there are only certain destined girls in the world who can possibly be the slayer, which plays a large part in the last season.
 
At the end of the first season, Buffy is drowned by the Master, but is resuscitated by Angel. This, of course, fucks everything up, leading to the second season where it is revealed that because Buffy was technically dead, albeit for a few minutes, a new slayer was called, though new slayer dies and the character of Faith is introduced as the replacement slayer. Faith turns evil, Buffy beats her down, and Faith slowly returns to being good. Cut to the last season.
 
Now the First, who is basically the source of all evil, sets out on a Hitler final solution type plan: kill every girl who would ever become a slayer before they have a chance to. This culminates into a spell being cast by Buffy and pals to giving every potential slayer their powers instantly. So to sum it all up, there are now a million super powered girls running around the world killing vampires.
 
I'm not exactly sure why I was compelled to write all that out, as nobody really asked, but now you know and knowing is half the battle.
 
Edit: and now I realize hagridore wrote everything I said in a sentence >.< that's what I get for not reading comments thoroughly.
Radio_Resistanceon Dec. 2, 2010 at 2:58 p.m.
No! No! Good for him! Whedon's Buffy is iconic. While I don't oppose this remake (worked for BSG), I would prefer Whedon keeps it separate from his version. If he is too involved, it would really just be a watered down Buffy that sort of resembles what we loved. I won't turn my nose up at it, but it should be radically different than Whedon's show for me to invest time into it.
JeffGoldblumon Dec. 2, 2010 at 7:18 p.m.
Well when she moved to the new town at the beginning of the series she didn't have time for cheer leading and became a social out cast. 
@handlas said:
" well the show had 2 slayers at one point.  I can't remember why.  It feels like so long ago.  Then the other slayer turned evil and hot slayer on slayer action ensued. "
Buffy drowned at the end of the first season and was "dead" for a matter of seconds before being revived. Thus, another Slayer was called. She was killed after only a few episodes, so a third a slayer was called, named Faith. Faith turned evil and eventually teamed up with the Mayor of Sunnydale. 
@TheEggplant said:
" They sort of retconned the "once every generation" thing in season 7 
And this story has been grossly misreported."
Yeah, Season 7 got nuts. Also, if you delve into the "Season 8" comics, shit really gets crazy. Buffy is leading an international team of slayers.
BradGrenzon Dec. 2, 2010 at 8:45 p.m.
The producers of the reboot may have reached out to Whedon, but we don't know what capacity they wanted him in. I suspect they wanted some kind of "blessing". There's no indication they wanted him to write and direct this project. It was greenlit based on someone else's pitch. So while the reboot producers are clearly just engaged in a little PR war here, it's not clear the offer Whedon "passed" on was a good one.
Levioon Dec. 3, 2010 at 2:05 a.m.
You have no idea how many times I have recommended a Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Twilight crossover.  It was a lot.

Dig Deeper into Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Buffy the Vampire Slayer is an American TV show created by Joss Whedon. It follows the trials and tribulations of Buffy Summers, the latest in a line of women known as "Slayers." As a Slayer she must battle against demons, vampires and other forces of darkness.

Edit/View the Wiki
Hit the Forums (9 Posts)
Add/View Images (2430 Images)
Watch Some Videos
Loki Won't be in Avengers 2

The main villain throughout the first Avengers won't be returning for another round of chaos.

Sony Already Has Plans for more Spider-Man

Hope you really want some more web slinging action.

Girl Meets World Series Ordered by Disney

The series sequel to the beloved Boy Meets World will see the light of day it seems.

Mary Jane Not to be in Amazing Spider-Man 2

I hope you wanted more Emma Stone.

Check Out Showtime's New Show Ray Donovan

Weeks ahead of its premiere Showtime lets you check out their new show.

$50 Movie Ticket Becomes a Reality...Sort of...

Would you be willing to pay more for a movie ticket if you got more out of it?

James Gandolfini Has Passed Away

The actor best known for his role as Tony Soprano has died suddenly.

DVD/Blu-Ray Releases for June 18th

Some of the year's disappointing movies and best TV are coming to home video.

Loki Won't be in Avengers 2

The main villain throughout the first Avengers won't be returning for another round of chaos.

Community Showcase for June 17th

Another week's worth of awesomeness straight from users just like you.

James Gandolfini Has Passed Away

The actor best known for his role as Tony Soprano has died suddenly.

Sony Already Has Plans for more Spider-Man

Hope you really want some more web slinging action.

Community Call!

Want to see something you write on the front page of Screened?

$50 Movie Ticket Becomes a Reality...Sort of...

Would you be willing to pay more for a movie ticket if you got more out of it?

Girl Meets World Series Ordered by Disney

The series sequel to the beloved Boy Meets World will see the light of day it seems.

DVD/Blu-Ray Releases for June 18th

Some of the year's disappointing movies and best TV are coming to home video.

Recent Reviews
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel