Screened News

My Experience with Christmas Lady Stories and the Reminder that Movies Don’t Have to Be Brilliant to be Delightful

In the cynical world of film criticism, it took several viewings of Made for TV movies to remind me that it isn’t always about the quality as much as the experience of watching a film

Oh, hello Ms. Christine Taylor. You are splendid in Farewell, Mr. Kringle
Oh, hello Ms. Christine Taylor. You are splendid in Farewell, Mr. Kringle

While I published two features with a full list of all of my favorite holiday movies, I have to be honest with you, I missed some. Now, why would I do that, you ask? Well, because it is kind of embarrassing. I admitted it on the recent Pupcast, but to write about it is a little different. All right, here goes. Are you ready? I love and am addicted to Christmas Lady Stories.

What is a Christmas Lady Story, you ask? Well, it is pretty much any movie that can be found on the Hallmark Channel or Lifetime during the month of December. Yes, you read that right, Hallmark and Lifetime. In general they are known as Made for TV movies, but I think it is much more appropriate to call them Lady Stories. Before you immediately close this story and go back to watching Lethal Weapon or Die Hard, hear me out. The lady doesn't refer to the ladies that watch them, but rather the ladies that are IN them. In a time when even holiday movies can be cynical, violent, depressing there is one thing that you can always count on in a lady story – at least one, and hopefully two moments that you might find some wet stuff making a puddle in your eye. Now, I probably should clarify, because they are not altogether uplifting. In fact, the vast majority of them deal with a poor widow that just lost her job and no longer has a home or family during the holidays. However, that is the best part. While the characters in lady stories always begin down on their luck, by the end of two hours things always get better. They meet the man of their dreams or are taken in by the local shop keeper who teaches that family doesn't have to be thought of in the traditional sense. In the end, they learn their life can always get worse, but we should be thankful for what we have and then it will improve. Also, life always gets better at Christmas.

While this isn’t necessarily true in real life, it is an amusing genre of movies to watch. I have spent the last few weeks switching shifting between watching Lady Stories and catching up on every movie I happened to miss recently so I am fully prepared for my Best of 2012 list that will be coming next week. That has been "quite the experience." Going back and forth from watching literally the finest cinematic movies of the year juxtaposed with, well, some of the worst. However, my enjoyment of them both is probably about at the same level. They simply serve different purposes. In fact, it has been a fun journey because it reminds me that a movie doesn’t necessarily have to be technically brilliant, or have perfect actors (or have a story that makes sense) to be enjoyable. I just watched a poor man play Secret Santa to an entire town just because he wants to do a good deed and while the overall quality could have been better, I loved every minute of the movie.

So, the next time you are flipping through the channels, and go by what could be a lady story (because you see a big city girl stuck in a small town meeting the local carpenter for the first time before she realizes the meaning of Christmas the night before it happens) I ask you stay on it for a moment. Join me in remembering that for all of us who make movies a huge part of our daily lives, they don't have to be perfect, they just have to be entertaining, and that can mean different things to everyone. It's the beauty of art and film and being a human.

That is all for now. I have to go watch Kevin Sorbo become little Olivia Meade’s “dad” after the old lady in the abandoned house makes wishes come true in Christmas Angel.

Ashwynon Dec. 20, 2012 at 3:25 p.m.

Oddly enough i just watched Kevin Sorbo in the made for tv movie; The Santa Suit.

More on topic, i find that Christmas made for tv movies are usually WAY more bearable than the usual Hallmark stuff.

FinalDasa staff on Dec. 20, 2012 at 3:51 p.m.

I wondered who watched those lol I say movies you enjoy are all that matter.

There are plenty of movies that come out that I know arent going to win awards or impress others but I get enjoyment out watching it and isn't that's all that matters

BradGrenzon Dec. 20, 2012 at 8:59 p.m.

My mother and my sisters constantly torture me with Lifetime and Hallmark Channel originals during the holidays. I was recently subjected to the tale of an elf played by Summer Glau who was apparently sent to a family in order to shame the parents and bang the uncle.

obscurefanon Dec. 21, 2012 at 2:05 a.m.

No matter how many times I hear it, Christmas Lady Stories always makes me laugh. Great article Stacey.

Cynically_Happyon Dec. 21, 2012 at 7:30 p.m.

For a second, having only read maybe the first line or two of the article and having seen the header image, I assumed that you loved all movies in which the role of Santa was filled by a female (most likely his daughter or maybe just some random woman who needed to learn some kind of lesson in the holiday spirit). I was then gonna remark on the hyper-specificity of that subset of movies, then I actually read the article.

Loki Won't be in Avengers 2

The main villain throughout the first Avengers won't be returning for another round of chaos.

Sony Already Has Plans for more Spider-Man

Hope you really want some more web slinging action.

Girl Meets World Series Ordered by Disney

The series sequel to the beloved Boy Meets World will see the light of day it seems.

Check Out Showtime's New Show Ray Donovan

Weeks ahead of its premiere Showtime lets you check out their new show.

Let’s Talk About Mad Men: “The Quality of Mercy”

Well, now we know what Bob Benson is all about.

8-bit Star Trek

Miss the 2009 Start Trek? Catch up really quickly through the eyes of a video game.

Is the Film Industry About to Completely Change?

Are we about to pay $25 a ticket? Are marketing budgets and blockbuster films ruining it for everyone else?

What To Watch for Thursday June 13th

Thursdays are starting to heat back up for the summer.

Loki Won't be in Avengers 2

The main villain throughout the first Avengers won't be returning for another round of chaos.

Community Showcase for June 17th

Another week's worth of awesomeness straight from users just like you.

$50 Movie Ticket Becomes a Reality...Sort of...

Would you be willing to pay more for a movie ticket if you got more out of it?

Community Call!

Want to see something you write on the front page of Screened?

Sony Already Has Plans for more Spider-Man

Hope you really want some more web slinging action.

Girl Meets World Series Ordered by Disney

The series sequel to the beloved Boy Meets World will see the light of day it seems.

Is the Film Industry About to Completely Change?

Are we about to pay $25 a ticket? Are marketing budgets and blockbuster films ruining it for everyone else?

Check Out Showtime's New Show Ray Donovan

Weeks ahead of its premiere Showtime lets you check out their new show.

Recent Reviews
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel