Screened News

Scenester: The Little Girl In The Red Coat From Schindler's List

A harrowing image, from one of the most powerful films ever made. This is one that stays with you.

The power of cinema.
The power of cinema.

There’s really no questioning the fact that Schindler’s List is one of the greatest American films ever made. It’s a piece that's chock full of emotionally powerful moments that stay with you long after the lights have come up. One image in particular, however, stands out for me as a truly iconic and haunting at the same time… the little girl in the red coat.

As with most great scenes, you really need to understand its context to truly appreciate it. The film opens up during the early stages of World War 2 after Nazi Germany has invaded Poland and is in the process of relocating Polish Jews to the Kraków Ghetto. A German businessman by the name of Oskar Schindler intends to profit off of the war effort and bribes Nazi officials in order to win military contracts. With the help of Jewish businessmen, Schindler is able to procure funds to start a factory and hires Polish Jews to work in his factory for wages that are in turn given to the Germany army. Although Schindler’s workers are allowed to leave the Ghetto and are somewhat protected from the horrors other Jews face, Schindler himself is still doing all of this for his own personal benefit rather than out of some altruistic intention. The sequence with the little girl in the red coat marks a turning point in the story for Schindler, which only adds to the emotional complexity of the piece. Check out the scene:

The first thing you notice, of course, is that the film was shot in black-and-white. This choice was made to heighten the documentary style feel of the cinematography. It also makes the introduction of color in this scene an extremely powerful moment. The girl’s red coat is the only time (not including the credits sequence and Shabat candles) that color appears in the film. Before I delve any deeper, here’s a quote from Spielberg himself about the image:

America and Russia and England all knew about the Holocaust when it was happening, and yet we did nothing about it. We didn't assign any of our forces to stopping the march toward death, the inexorable march toward death. It was a large bloodstain, primary red color on everyone's radar, but no one did anything about it. And that's why I wanted to bring the color red in.

Spielberg has stated many times that shooting this film was a deeply emotional process for him, and you definitely get a sense of that from the quote above. Using Spielberg’s quote as a jumping off point, the girl in the red coat is the most obvious symbol in the entire film. In this scene, she walks around seemingly oblivious to the horrors unfolding around her. In a way, she represents Spielberg’s own feelings on the inaction of world powers in stopping this genocide from unfolding. They were blind to the horrors unfolding right before their very eyes. And, as Spielberg mentions, red is symbolic of a “bloodstain”. By bringing in such a distinct color over a relatively small area in a black-and-white film, you really feel that this is a stain you can never wash away.

Children are associated with innocence and, in this scene, the little girl also represents the innocence of the Jews being rounded up and murdered in the streets of the Ghetto. Getting back to Oskar Schindler for a moment, this scene is a literal representation of what his character is starting to understand and finally accept. He sees the innocence and purity in this young girl in the midst of all this chaos (which is a very striking contrast) and realizes that these people are just as innocent as her. It’s a horrible reality that’s made all the worse for him a later in the film as he sees the girl’s dead body being carted off. For Schindler, these are not merely strangers or workers in his factory anymore, they’re human beings who are being murdered by a truly sinister force. His internal conflict is playing out right before his eyes in the external conflict taking place below him.

Quite possibly Liam Neeson's finest performance.
Quite possibly Liam Neeson's finest performance.

The cinematography seen here beautifully heightens these emotions. Much of the scene is filmed in long shots. We as an audience are seeing things unfold from Schindler’s POV atop the overlook. We view action unfolding, but are never directly in the middle of them. It quite literally turns us into onlookers as these unspeakable horrors unfold and we feel as Schindler does in this very moment… completely helpless. It also makes a very bold statement to the audience. It's as if the camera is asking what you would do at the moment? In an indirect way, it makes us take on a level of guilt as we stand there and watch with Schindler. Again, it's the exact emotion our main character is felling as well. Schindler’s POV is also from an elevated position, which mirrors his feelings prior to this point. He’s a businessman and turning a profit is his sole concern. He’s above all of the conflict and bloodshed going on with this war, because he’s merely an opportunist. The use of the camera here directly serves his dramatic character shift.

You also can’t ignore the music played throughout the scene. Like the little girl, it’s in sharp contrast to the brutality of the images displayed onscreen. It’s also not an accident that children are singing the song. It really hammers home the theme of innocence that the little girl encapsulates. The somber tune also sets the tragic tone of the scene and creates a very haunting mood. It’s definitely designed to work together with the other elements at play here to make the moment stick with you long after the credits roll.

Another interesting note is that the little girl in the red coat is based on an actual person named Roma Ligocka, who, unlike the character, survived the Holocaust. She, however, was not actually involved in the making of the film. Instead, the character was constructed from the memories of Holocaust survivors Spielberg had interviewed prior to filming. Roma was known around the Ghetto for her unmistakable red coat. She actually saw the film without knowing she was in it and was shocked to see "herself" on the big screen. All of this happened purely by accident, since Spielberg was piecing bits and pieces together from many sources.

Schindler's List is a monumental piece of filmmaking. It's a harrowing and extremely powerful film that has brought many grown men to tears. Seriously, the final scene with Oskar is one of the most moving endings I have ever seen. Schindler's List a testament to just how great of a filmmaker Steven Spielberg truly is. It's one that I think everyone should watch at least once.

Rominationon July 20, 2011 at 12:04 p.m.

The girl in the red dress was actually one of the few things that I knew about Schindler's List when I went in. I'd been shown the scene out of context but actually watching it later was a lot more of a powerful thing.

StealthMaster86on July 20, 2011 at 12:14 p.m.
This is one film I've been meaning to watch for a long time.
teh_destroyeron July 20, 2011 at 12:15 p.m.

I haven't watched it in such a long time, Liam Neeson was so freaking good in it.

DirtyOldBumon July 20, 2011 at 12:24 p.m.

God this world sucks, but I'm tired of hearing about how the allied forces should of tried harder to stop the genocide. You think a country that is firebombing civilian cities, killing millions, is gonna risk attacking camps that have no military value. Morality is almost never a factor in war. Geneva conventions be damned. May science and technology make mankind obsolete.

Fergon July 20, 2011 at 12:27 p.m.
Excellent stuff Andrew, really interesting and informative piece!
Artieon July 20, 2011 at 12:35 p.m.
THIS WATCH! 
 
TEN PEOPLE! 
 
I could've done more. 
 
 
What always stuck with me in this film was the generational saving that Schindler did. It's easy to see a few thousand jews were saved because of him but it goes further than that. In today's world, those Jews have had kids and familes. Instead of just having a few thousand people saved by Schindler, there are entire families that wouldn't exist without him. That's what I found amazing about this film and his actions in real life. There's a literal "Schindler Jews" population in the world.
Iconon July 20, 2011 at 12:58 p.m.
The girl in the red dress absolutely killed me with how effective it was. When Oscar sees her red coat among the refuse, well I just lost it. 
risselesson July 20, 2011 at 1:02 p.m.

Hands down, one of the best movies ever made.

Yelixon July 20, 2011 at 1:02 p.m.

The problem with that scene is that I barely notice that it's red. I'm slightly color deficient, but I think it might just be a really subtle shade of red.

EDIT: On topic, yeah, it's a really incredible and powerful touch that makes an incredible movie that much better. I had to get up and take a break halfway through the last time I watched it. I couldn't handle it all at once.

Mistress_Redheadon July 20, 2011 at 1:08 p.m.
@AndrewGodoski: Did you know this particular red coat style of cinema flashes etc was paying homage (stealing depending on who you talk too) to an older film called Don't Look Now
 
With the killer dwarf in the red coat 
Grimmy616on July 20, 2011 at 1:19 p.m.
I just want to say. Just thinking about this movies ending makes me hold back tears. When Neeson breaks down and thinks he hasn't done enough is one of the best and saddest moments 'ive seen in a movie.
phrosniteon July 20, 2011 at 2:18 p.m.
I admit I haven't seen this movie and probably never will...
ursa1979on July 20, 2011 at 2:43 p.m.
I am not a bit cryer, and I do not say that to be tough. It is just fact.... it takes quite a bit to make me cry. But every time I see this movie, specifically this scene. I ball my eyes out. My wife and I (girlfriend at the time) were living in a poor minneapolis apt. and she had never seen the movie before. Together we drank a bottle of wine and cried till the sun came up. It is one of my most significant memories.
mylifeforAiuron July 20, 2011 at 4:48 p.m.
The ending to Schindler's List absolutely destroys me every time I see it; Neeson is brilliant and without a doubt at the top of his game as Oskar.
PieINyourFACEon July 20, 2011 at 5:31 p.m.

The and scene makes me bawl.

obonicuson July 20, 2011 at 6:46 p.m.

I always thought that scene was kind of hacky and unnecessary. It's as if Spielberg doesn't believe that we can identify with all the horrible stuff the nazis are doing, so he throws in a cute little kid to tug on our heartstrings, and then offs her so he can properly hit us over the head with the point.

AndrewGodoski staff on July 20, 2011 at 7:10 p.m.

@Mistress_Redhead: I did indeed know. I actually got to see it on a big screen. Jack Bauer's pops for the win.

myketunaon July 20, 2011 at 8:05 p.m.

Probably going to watch this movie very soon based on this scene. It didn't affect me too much watching it, but I'm guessing it's because I saw it out of context in a youtube embedding.

pescado_auf_deutschon July 20, 2011 at 8:26 p.m.

been a long time. will probably watch this again soon.

Akridon July 20, 2011 at 8:35 p.m.
I'd like to watch this movie again just to try and understand the nuances a bit better, but it honestly seems a bit perverse... It almost feels like Schindler's List is something you suffer through for the betterment of oneself,  and not something that bears repeated viewings.

Dig Deeper into Schindler's List

Based on the novel, Schindler's Ark, Nazi war-profiteer Oskar Schindler founds an enamelware factory with Polish slave labor during the Holocaust. After witnessing the horrors of Nazi oppression, he conspires to shelter over 1100 workers from deportment to Auschwitz concentration camp. The film was nominated for 12 academy awards and won 7.

Edit/View the Wiki
Hit the Forums (1 Post)
Add/View Images (197 Images)
Watch Some Videos
Let’s Talk About Mad Men: “Man with a Plan”

Well... that was creepy.

Kill Phil Builds Boba Fett's Blaster

Watch as a someone goes from picture to reality in only a day or two.

What To Watch for Tuesday May 14th

Tuesdays march on a the most mediocre night of the week with no reason why.

Screen Addict Has an Extra Long Take on Great Gatsby

Watch a not so 60 second review of The Great Gatsby.

Full Trailer for Agents of SHIELD

Check out the full trailer for the upcoming Marvel TV show all about SHIELD.

Netflix Instant Update for May 16th

A few animated shows are leaving but a few more are coming in to help replace those cartoon filled nights.

About Last Night: Revolution "The Longest Day"

A long day to look back and realize all your interpersonal relationships are more dysfunctial than the Bluths.

DVD/Blu-Ray Releases for May 14th

This week's DVD/Blu-Ray releases gives me yet another excuse to talk about wrestling.

Angry Birds will be a Movie

Sony Pictures now holds the rights to the huge downloadable title.

Netflix Instant Update for May 16th

A few animated shows are leaving but a few more are coming in to help replace those cartoon filled nights.

TNT/TBS the First to Start Streaming

Time Warner now offering full streaming for two of their more popular channels.

Full Trailer for Agents of SHIELD

Check out the full trailer for the upcoming Marvel TV show all about SHIELD.

Full Pacific Rim Trailer

The full trailer is released and this monster/robot movie looks better and better.

Riddick Trailer

The trailer for the third film is this trilogy looks pretty badass.

Last Vegas Trailer

Remember how you didn't want a Hangover 3? Will how about with old people?

TV Upfronts, By The Numbers

The Upfront report is back to give you a quick rundown about the state of network TV.

Recent Reviews
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel