Screened News

This Fan-Made John Carter Trailer Actually Makes It Look Mildly Interesting

It's amazing what dedicated amateurs can do, given time and a bit of care.

I should be John Carter's target audience, but all of Disney's marketing has made it look like a sub-par superhero-vs-aliens movie taking place in a vast, boring desert expanse. A bit too similar to Cowboys And Aliens, in other words. The trailers have seemed...respectful, perhaps, to the film, but didn't do much to excite me. I'm not going to claim that the fan trailer above, uploaded a week or so ago by a fan site for the film, necessarily changes my mind, but it at least tells the story of the film in a cogent manner, which is more than most of the official trailers can claim to have done.

Are you looking forward to John Carter? Does the trailer above change your opinions about it in any way?

roboon Feb. 23, 2012 at 5:29 a.m.

It's not the trailer that puts me off of this movie. It's just about everything else.

The casting and the snippets of their perfomances shown, the effects, the setting, the costume and character design, what little they did convey of the plot/premise (another old 'outsider saves the natives, gets the girl' type of story dug up and made into a movie). It all just feels...trite. And a bit cheesy to boot.

LokitheNightlordon Feb. 23, 2012 at 7:50 a.m.

I actually thought the first John Carter trailer with Peter Gabriel playing in the background looked pretty good. This new trailer was also pretty good and the film itself doesn't look bad. It annoys me that everyone calls John Carter a rip-off of other stuff, but it's based on a book that was written 100 years ago.

thecosmicflyon Feb. 23, 2012 at 10:37 a.m.

As a plebeian who had (And somewhat still has) little to no knowledge about John Carter or the many Edgar Rice Burroughs novels this film is based off, I can safely say that the original trailers did nothing to tell me what the Goddamn hell was going on. Seeing that fan edit trailer on the other hand with the new footage of John Carter on Earth was enough to help clear up a lot of questions I had.

Well hopefully now Disney will start to ramp up the marketing and get this into the public’s eye well before it comes out. When’s the release date again?

This film is doomed.

Bones8677on Feb. 23, 2012 at 4:47 p.m.

Was that an epic version of 'Come With Me' in that trailer?

ThePhantomStrangeron Feb. 23, 2012 at 7:04 p.m.

@ryanwho said:

Mildly interesting is an overstatement. Not sure what that fan trailer is supposed to do for me that the other one didn't. Guess I'm not a fan of something that only exists in the wake of Avatar when Avatar wasn't an especially good film to begin with. White boy saves the tribe. Nah I'm good.

This.

Rhombus_Of_Terroron Feb. 23, 2012 at 7:13 p.m.

@Bones8677 said:

Was that an epic version of 'Come With Me' in that trailer?

no, "Kashmir" by Led Zepplin.

Bones8677on Feb. 24, 2012 at 4:55 p.m.

@RhombusOfTerror said:

@Bones8677 said:

Was that an epic version of 'Come With Me' in that trailer?

no, "Kashmir" by Led Zepplin.

Crap, they're the SAME song!

selbieon Feb. 26, 2012 at 12:56 a.m.

I didn't really need a good trailer to be interested in this film, but before seeing this, I wouldn't have known that John Carter came from earth at the time of what looks like the industrial era.

So Disney, fire your marketing team and start hiring some talented people.

Moviemaniacon Feb. 27, 2012 at 10:44 a.m.

@ryanwho:

Avatar is John Carter, not the other way around. Get your facts straight.

SSullyon Feb. 27, 2012 at 5:05 p.m.

@selbie said:

I didn't really need a good trailer to be interested in this film, but before seeing this, I wouldn't have known that John Carter came from earth at the time of what looks like the industrial era.

So Disney, fire your marketing team and start hiring some talented people.

Seriously, I had no idea that he was an average man. I assumed he jumped super high because of the gravity difference, but they made him out to be some super hero or something. I am actually interesting in this film now.

Dig Deeper into John Carter

A man dealing with the loss of his family in the Civil War ends up transported to Mars in this fantasy epic.

Edit/View the Wiki
Hit the Forums (13 Posts)
Add/View Images (112 Images)
Watch Some Videos (4 Videos)
After Ted Sarandos, Will Hollywood ever be the same?

An interview with the man behind the content of Netflix reveals an interesting and passionate executive.

Community Showcase for May 20th

Batman is here this week to present to you your Community Showcase.

About Last Night: Game of Thrones: "Second Sons"

Marriage marriage is what brings us together today.

Xbox One Hopes to Change Your Entertainment Habits

Will the next set of consoles change the way we consume our media?

Disney/Lucasfilm Announce New Animated Star Wars Show

There won't be anymore clones but Disney wants to stay in the animated Star Wars arena.

Let’s Talk About Mad Men: “The Crash”

This episode had everything: comedy, drugs, mayhem, flashbacks, emotion—what more do you need?

This Wolverine Trailer Finally Feels Complete

A new Wolverine trailer reveals a more soulful and desperate Wolverine, which could be a good thing.

What To Watch for Tuesday May 21st

Not much on a Tuesday night but there is a season finale.

DVD/Blu-Ray Releases for May 21st

There may be a lot of Blu-Rays released but only a few you should really care about.

The Top 10 Vietnam War Movies

The Best List is here to run down the best films to capture the essence of the Vietnam war.

Disney/Lucasfilm Announce New Animated Star Wars Show

There won't be anymore clones but Disney wants to stay in the animated Star Wars arena.

Anchorman 2 Teaser

It isn't much but it is our first look at the returning characters of Anchorman 2.

What To Watch for Wednesday, May 22nd

Wednesday brings the thunder!

Screen Addict: Gremlins 3 and Beetlejuice news

If you were looking forward to a Gremlins 3 and a good Beetlejuice film, I'm sorry in advance.

After Ted Sarandos, Will Hollywood ever be the same?

An interview with the man behind the content of Netflix reveals an interesting and passionate executive.

Netflix Instant Update for May 23rd

There may not be a whole lot coming to Netflix, but there are some decent titles worth checking out.

Recent Reviews
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel