Let's All Pretend That Spike Lee Is Going to Direct the Oldboy Remake Now

Topic started by Alex on July 6, 2011. Last post by lionellaflare 1 year, 10 months ago.
Post by Alex (325 posts) See mini bio
Moderator

No matter how many times we hear that the long-in-development remake of Park Chan-wook's 2003 revenge thriller, Oldboy, is dead on the table, someone just keeps bringing that thing back to life.

Twitch is currently reporting (via those perpetually pesky "sources") that the project is back on the table, and that among possibilities for directors, Spike Lee is the one currently at the forefront.

Lee, who hasn't directed a film since 2008, had recently spoken to Charlie Rose about his myriad issues trying to get films produced of late, including a sequel to his most successful movie, The Inside Man. The Hollywood Reporter has quotes from the interview, if you're interested.

If Twitch's sources are correct, then perhaps Lee does have something in the pipes. It's an intriguing pick for a project that, at one point, drew interest from the likes of Steven Spielberg and Will Smith. The script is reportedly rooted far more heavily in the original manga that the film was adapted from, but considering how many transitions this project has gone through over the last few years, who even knows what is real and what is conjecture at this point?

While most every part of my soul just wishes this project would die a quiet, unremarkable death, I have to admit: the Spike Lee pick is an intriguing one. I suppose we'll just have to see where, if anywhere at all, this goes.

Post by psychpunk (271 posts) See mini bio
This is prob one remake I would actually deny the existence of if it came out regardless of who directed. I'd be there with the Millennium Trilogy if it wasn't David Fincher.
Post by Popo (161 posts) See mini bio
I'm with you Alex, hopefully this will die
Post by Vincemaster (409 posts) See mini bio
Please let this die. Even if it does come out the plot will be cleaned up and altered beyond recognition. We already have a near perfect film with Oldboy, why try to recreate a masterpiece that already worked so well the first time?
Post by Monkeyman04 (350 posts) See mini bio
@Vincemaster said:
Please let this die. Even if it does come out the plot will be cleaned up and altered beyond recognition. We already have a near perfect film with Oldboy, why try to recreate a masterpiece that already worked so well the first time?
My thoughts exactly. 
Post by Milkman (645 posts) See mini bio

This doesn't need to exist.

Post by Skogen (45 posts) See mini bio

Oldboy; A Spike Lee Joint

Post by tgammet (47 posts) See mini bio

Oh god, just realized that image is moving. Make it stop!!

Post by ScanCase (893 posts) See mini bio
Moderator

god kill me now. I don't mind remakes if the original could use some improvement but oldboy is virtually perfect the way it is. you can only go down hill from here.

Post by Erotolepsy (61 posts) See mini bio

Don't know why so many people are down on this news -- Let Me In seemed to be well liked around here and it was a perfect example of a movie that didn't exactly improve on the original while still doing enough to present its own unique vision.
 
Above all else, Oldboy was a movie with a fairly simple plot that let its distinct, striking visuals do most of its speaking for it. I can think of few American directors that I would trust more with that kind of project, even if Miracle at St. Anna was a bit of a snoozer -- so I will continue dreaming.
Post by psychpunk (271 posts) See mini bio
Post by PenguinDust (1,685 posts) See mini bio
@Skogen said:

Oldboy; A Spike Lee Joint

That's the reason I hope these rumors are true.  ;-)
 
If not that then Tyler Perry's Oldboy.
Post by Paulrus (301 posts) See mini bio
If Spike Lee remakes Oldboy I may have to punch something. I just don't think the idea works.
Post by LoktarOgar (41 posts) See mini bio
The script is reportedly rooted far more heavily in the original manga that the film was adapted from
 
This is a baaaaaaaaaaaad idea, since the movie is infinitely better. On the other hand, the manga also lacks all parts that make the Korean movie one that would never ever be remade in the US, so I can see why they'd go that route, but it's still not for the better of the movie, at all.
Post by vinsanityv22 (375 posts) See mini bio
If it doesn't happen, whatever. If it does happen, I'll pay attention to it. Could be cool to see Spike Lee's take on this manga. I mean, that's ideally how you want people to look at adaptations/remakes -- "it's someone else's take on something; let's see what 'flavor' they bring to things". It's just that, far too often, Hollywood just makes sh**. Just complete, utter, horsesh**. I don't think Spike Lee would put out horsesh**, so if he brings this movie to fruition, so be it -- I'll check it out. 
 
Maybe. 
 
If it dies, I don't really care either.
Post by mylifeforAiur (1,662 posts) See mini bio

Oldboy is fine the way it is... Brilliantly twisted and deplorable.

Post by Lydian_Sel (2,023 posts) See mini bio
Even though I'm not for this, or really any remake, what's the worst Spike Lee of all directors could do?
Post by robokungfu (167 posts) See mini bio
This "going back to the source material" is nonsense. NO ONE in Hollywood would give a shit about this property if it weren't for the Park film. There's so many manga titles out there and all of the sudden Hollywood cares about Oldboy? Keep your grubby hands off and think up your own material. 
Post by sofacitysweetheart (21 posts) See mini bio
Because the original version isn't perfect? Oh Hollywood, you make me want to cry :(
Post by lionellaflare (30 posts) See mini bio
Please don't touch this film.... T_T
Just do a FANTASTIC dub and release it in north america..
160 votes, 4.6 avg.

  • B

  • 3.8

  • 74

  • 8.3
General Information Edit
Name Oldboy
US Release March 25, 2005
UK Release Oct. 15, 2004
AUS Release March 3, 2005
Runtime 120
Language(s)
Add a new language
Genre(s)
Add a new genre
Theme(s)
Add a new theme
Rating R
Alias(es) Old Boy
Top Rated Lists
Mindbenders a list of 32 items by Strange_Bundle
My top Films a list of 47 items by ScanCase
  • In today's dollars
    Domestic $707,481
    Foreign +14,272,524
  • = total worldwide gross $14,980,005
  • - a reported budget of $4,000,000
  • = a 274.5% net profit of $10,980,005
Top Editors
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel