1987 Star Trek: The Next Generation Casting Memo Reveals Choices that Never Were

Topic started by Matt on Aug. 26, 2010. Last post by Sharpless 2 years, 9 months ago.
Post by Matt (666 posts) See mini bio
Staff

 "Who&squot;s the big man now, Picard!"
 "Who's the big man now, Picard!"
Gene Roddenberry's iconic second (major) stab at his most famous property, Star Trek: The Next Generation  has been in syndication and a staple of late-night TV watching for, well, just about a generation now. I myself just saw one of my favorite episodes the other night by chance, "The Inner Light," and still marvel at how well the show's held up...other than little things like the Starfleet PADD is actually just an iPad. 
 
Things could have been different though. Drastically different. The site Letters of Note, led by editor Shaun Usher (no pun intended...mostly), is devoted to bringing to light historical or just plain interesting written correspondences and dug up an old casting memo for ST:TNG from 1987 that reveals some truly fascinating possibilities. The letter between two Paramount execs, John Pike and then-head of TV John Ferraro, details who producers were seriously looking at to come in and read for Roddenberry. I've posted an image of the memo after the jump, but some quick interesting tidbits include:  

  • Belgian actor Patrick Bauchau was neck-in-neck for the role of Capt. Picard. (Perhaps this is why his character's name in 2012 was Picard.) Also, Yaphet Kotto was at least on their short list. That would have been amazing.
  • Denise Crosby, who eventually played Tasha Yar for a short time, was considered the "only possibility" for Counselor Troi. 
  • The role of Tasha seems to originally have been slated for Rosalind Chao, who later went on to be Chief O'Brien's wife and play a larger role in DS9
  • Wil Wheaton wasn't even being considered for Wesley Crusher at the time. That role seemed destined for J.D. Roth, of all people.
 
But the coup de gras has to be the one actor among many being considered for the part of Chief Engineer Geordi LaForge that I absolutely. Did. Not. See. Coming. I'm not going to tell you who that is because I can't be held responsible for any demolition on your brain, man. You'll just have to look at the memo yourself below. Thanks go out to user Count_Zero for pointing me in the direction of this jewel.
  
 

Post by CrazyCraven (275 posts) See mini bio
Wesley Snipes are Geordi - Thats nuts!! But  Yaphet Kotto would have been amazing as Picard. 
Post by OldGuy (130 posts) See mini bio
Reggie Jackson???!!!!?
 
-=*BOOM*=-
 
wait, wait, wait... nah, can't be that Reggie Jackson... wasn't he still playing... <searching...>
Rats, he signed a 1 year contract with the A's in '87...
But, for a minute there my head really did aspode.
Post by Kraznor (461 posts) See mini bio

Kevin Peter Hall as either Data or Geordi would have been super weird. But yeah, Wesley Snipes.

Post by Sharpless (53 posts) See mini bio
Also, notice that Tim Russ was considered for Geordi. Assuming we're talking about the same Tim Russ, he eventually went on to play Tuvok on Voyager.
Post by Falconer (235 posts) See mini bio
@Sharpless said:
" Also, notice that Tim Russ was considered for Geordi. Assuming we're talking about the same Tim Russ, he eventually went on to play Tuvok on Voyager. "
I thought it was a well known fact that he auditioned for the role of Geordi... 
 
PS - I'm not a big Trek guy.
Post by gangly (1,273 posts) See mini bio
Some casting person, producer, or something must have had a serious thing for Denise Crosby, cause it seems like they were desperate to get her, only to... um... "loose" her relatively quickly.
Post by Walker_after_dark (238 posts) See mini bio
Reggie Jackson, wow. The only thing that could have made that more awesome would be if they had cast Billy Martin as Picard.
Post by hagridore (132 posts) See mini bio
Wesley f-ing Snipes.
Post by NateDogg (70 posts) See mini bio
Wesley Snipes as Geordi would had been ridiculous! I don't even know how awesome or awful it would have been. 
Post by CharAznable (329 posts) See mini bio
I'm just happy to see J.D. Roth get some props. Fun House, mother effers!
Post by Olivaw (779 posts) See mini bio
This is blowing my effing mind.
Post by Martin_Blank (472 posts) See mini bio
'G' in space.
Post by StormtrooprDave (582 posts) See mini bio
Holy shit! Yaphet Kotto as Picard?!?! Someone needs to make this video NAO!!  Throw in Andre Braugher as Worf and I will shit myself.
Post by DukeTogo (148 posts) See mini bio
Fuck all that, Jenny Agutter (misspelled on the memo) would have been the best damn Dr. Crusher ever.
Post by Arjuna (170 posts) See mini bio
I follow Levar Burton's twitter feed, and he confirmed that this memo is true.  It's been circulating quite a bit and went viral.  Lottsa people who know me to be a Star Trek fan forwarded me it.
Post by Parsnip (198 posts) See mini bio
Yeah, I saw this earlier, and my mind was blown.
Post by Sharpless (53 posts) See mini bio
@Falcon said:
" @Sharpless said:
" Also, notice that Tim Russ was considered for Geordi. Assuming we're talking about the same Tim Russ, he eventually went on to play Tuvok on Voyager. "
I thought it was a well known fact that he auditioned for the role of Geordi...  PS - I'm not a big Trek guy. "
I feel like I knew it at one point, but it had slipped my mind until I saw this. I don't imagine that it's too well known outside of Trek circles though, you notwithstanding. :)
General Information Edit
Name Star Trek: The Next Generation
Status Ended
Date of 1st Airing Sept. 26, 1987
Date of Last Airing May 23, 1994
Show Type
Original Air Day Monday
Original Air Time
Show Length 60
Network(s)
Syndicated
Language(s)
Add a new language
Genre(s)
Add a new genre
Theme(s)
Add a new theme
Alias(es) TNG
Top Rated Lists
The Pat Seal of Approval a list of 102 items by PatVB
Personal Checklist of things to watch a list of 84 items by The Poet
Favorite TV Series' a list of 141 items by SycoMantis91
Top Editors
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel