Forty-seven percent of US homeowners insurance customers experienced a premium increase in the past year, according to J.D. Power’s 2025 US Home Insurance Study — the highest rate of insurer-initiated increases the study has recorded in more than a decade.
The finding that should interest homeowners more is the second one: satisfaction did not fall in proportion to the size of the increase. It fell in proportion to whether the increase was explained.
The Communication Gap
Insurers that proactively contacted policyholders before a rate change — explaining the driver, whether it was catastrophe exposure, reinsurance cost, rebuild-cost inflation or a claim on the account — retained substantially higher satisfaction scores than those that let the renewal notice deliver the news.
This is not a soft finding. Satisfaction correlates tightly with retention, and retention is what determines whether a carrier has to keep buying new customers at acquisition cost. The study effectively documents that a large part of the industry is spending money to replace customers it lost for the price of a phone call.
Why Your Premium Went Up Even Without a Claim
Homeowners consistently misread rate increases as personal. They usually are not. The main drivers, roughly in order:
Reinsurance. Insurers buy insurance. That cost rose sharply after 2022 and has stayed high. It flows straight into primary rates regardless of your individual record.
Rebuild cost inflation. Most policies carry an automatic inflation adjustment on the dwelling limit. If construction costs rose 8%, your coverage amount rose with them — and so did the premium, without anything changing about your house.
Territory re-rating. Carriers have been redrawing risk maps, particularly for hail, wildfire and severe convective storm. Your ZIP code may have been re-classified even if your house did not change.
Roof age. This is the fastest-moving underwriting variable in the market. Many carriers now schedule roof payouts by age or decline to renew past a threshold.
What to Do When the Renewal Arrives
- Call and ask for the specific driver. You are entitled to know. If the answer is “general rate increase,” ask whether the dwelling limit moved, whether the territory was re-rated, and whether any surcharge was applied.
- Check the dwelling limit against a current rebuild estimate. Automatic inflation adjustments compound. After several years of them, a substantial number of policies are over-insured on the structure.
- Ask what discounts you are not receiving. Roof material, water shutoff devices, monitored alarms, claim-free tenure, paperless billing, bundling. Discounts are applied at issue and frequently never revisited.
- Get three competing quotes before you accept. Match the coverage form (HO-3 versus HO-5), the deductible structure — including any separate wind or hail percentage deductible — and the replacement cost basis. A cheaper premium on actual cash value for the roof is not a cheaper policy.
- Do not let it lapse while shopping. A gap in coverage is itself an underwriting negative and will follow you.
The Longer Arc
Rate increases have been the norm for five consecutive years. The rate of increase has begun to moderate as underwriting results improved across the industry, but “moderating” means smaller increases, not decreases.
The homeowners who fare best in this market are the ones who treat the policy as something to be re-tendered annually rather than renewed automatically. Loyalty carries no pricing benefit in property insurance, and in several states it carries a measurable penalty.
Source: J.D. Power, 2025 US Home Insurance Study
Compare carriers on price and claims handling in our home insurance guide.